America's First Amish Bishop

Google Image

My daughter-in-law Melissa Murphy Oliver has a 9th great-grandfather who was the first Amish bishop in America:  Jacob “Jakob” Hertzler (1703-1786). An Amish bishop “is the head of the individual church district, and is responsible for administering discipline, ordaining new ministry, baptizing, and marrying new members.”

The last name of Hertzler is commonly associated with being German. However, the geographic area where Jacob was born (Baden-Württemberg) spoke a Swiss-German dialect. And, Baden-Württemberg is located near the boundaries of Switzerland, Germany, and France.  Modern sources state Jacob Hertzler was born in Switzerland of Swiss parents. Jacob’s parents were probably Amish in that the history of the Amish church began in Switzerland. The beginning of the Amish church was a result of a schism within a group of Swiss and Alsatian Anabaptists in 1693 led by Jakob Ammann whose followers became known as Amish. 

Google Image

Jacob married twice. The name of his first wife is unknown. After her death, he married Catherine Knegy/Ruegy (1713-1773) with whom he had three children. Jacob and his family moved from Switzerland to the Palatinate (a province in northeast France), sometimes referred to as the Rhineland Palatinate. You will note on the map that this area is not that far from his hometown of Baden-Württemberg.

After being in France for only a few years, the Hertzlers decided to leave France for America due to religious persecution.  In 1749, the family booked passage on the ship “St. Andrew,” leaving from Rotterdam, Holland, stopping in Plymouth, England, and arriving at Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, in 9 September 1749. The six-week trip would take place in a small wooden ship. The voyage would not have been easy or pleasant. A passenger on a similar ship in 1750 described the voyage as follows:

“During the voyage there is on board these ships terrible misery, stench, fumes, horror, vomiting,

1750s sailing ship - Google images

many kinds of sickness, fever, dysentery, headache, heat, constipation, boils, scurvy, cancer, mouth rot, and the like, all of which come from old and sharply-salted food and meat, also from very bad and foul water, so that many die miserably.”

Amazingly, Jacob and his family survived the trip; and, upon arrival in Philadelphia, they headed to Northkill Creek, northwest of Philadelphia. As early as 1740, the Amish had established a settlement in the Northkill Watershed area in eastern Pennsylvania.  Having been ordained in Switzerland, Hertzler became this Amish community’s first pastor and bishop. 

In 1750 Jacob purchased over 182 acres from Richard and Thomas Penn about 10 miles northeast of Northkill Creek.  Over the years he purchased additional land, eventually having a tract of land of 404 acres and 4 perches (one perche = 5.5 yards). He cleared the timbered land, farmed, and named it Contentment. Today this property is located in Upper Berne Township in Berks County.

 

Google image

In 1757, an Indian massacre took place at Northkill Creek, and the town was abandoned. Many of the residents migrated to Lancaster, Mifflin, Somerset, and Union Counties, Pennsylvania. However, the Hertzlers, Jacob and Catherine stayed on their farm and eventually divided the land among their children.

An interesting side note about Jacob has to do with the “oath of allegiance.” When Jacob arrived in Philadelphia on September 9, 1749, he took the oath of allegiance (presumably to support the King of England, which was common at that time before the Revolution). An oath of allegiance is an oath where one acknowledges a duty of allegiance and swears loyalty to a monarch or a country. However, in 1778, he refused to take an oath of allegiance. Here is the text from Berks County court decision about his refusal to take the oath:

“Receive into your Custody the within Named who was brought before us to take and subscribe the oath or affirmation of allegiance and he did refuse and still refuse to take the same and safely keep for the space of three months from the day of the date hereof given under our hands and seals sixth day of July 1778. /s/ Charles Shoemaker, Justice

Jacob was fined 18 schillings and 4 pence. I have not been able to find out whether that oath was for Pennsylvania or for the “United Colonies.” Keep in mind, the United States of America did not officially exist until 21 June 1788.

Sample 1770 Oath of Allegiance - Google image

 

Sample 1777 Oath of Allegiance - Google image

Jacob and Catherine Hertzler are both buried in the Amish Congregation Burying Ground adjacent to what was his homestead. Though there are very old tombstones in the small cemetery, there are none for either Jacob or Catherine.

 

Burying Ground

About seven miles east of the former Northkill Creek community, there are memorial markers/memorial to both the community and Jacob Hertzler. In fact, his original home, still stands today and is occupied. The marker by the homestead labels the spot as “Contentment.” 

 

Hertzler Homestead - picture from Blog "Scribbler: Local Tourist"

It is hoped that Jacob and his family, by emigrating to this country, did, indeed, find contentment.

For sources and additional reading:

1 - “Biographic Memorial of Jacob Hertzler: and a Complete Genealogical Family Register of His Lineal Descendants and Those Related by inter-Marriage, from 1730 to 1883” 

2 – “Passage to America,1750” 

3 – “Scribbler: Local Tourist”

4 – “Who Leads the Amish Church?” 

A Coalminer's Daughter

She is by no means a coal miner’s daughter, but she is a great-granddaughter, a grandniece, and a great-grandniece of coal miners. I am talking about my daughter-in-law Melissa Murphy Oliver, and she is well acquainted with the dangers coal miners face.

Last week one of the people I highlighted was coal miner James Bernard Murphy – he died in a mine explosion in Everettville, a small town about seven miles southwest of Morgantown, West Virginia, and 82 miles straight south of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. 

On April 30, 1927, at 3:20 p.m., an explosion destroyed Federal No. 3 mine in Everettville, West

No. 3 Mine Explosion

Virginia, killing over 100 mine workers; only nine miners working that day managed to escape. After two weeks the fires, a result of the explosion, were finally put out and rescuers were able to recover the bodies still in the mine. It was determined that the explosion started as a result of an "storage-battery locomotive" ignited an accumulation of methane gas and coal dust.(see last photo). The mine was owned by the New England Fuel and Transportation Company.

Explosion Aftermath

In 2011, a memorial was dedicated to the memory of the coal miners – not only those that died on April 30, 1927, but also those that survived.  The names are inscribed on the 7.5 ton memorial overlooking the former mine site. There are a total of 149 names with the year of their death listed. Every year since the original dedication, there has been an annual memorial service. At this year’s memorial, United Mine Workers of American district 31 vice-president, Mike Caputo, made the following remarks:

            “When you’re a coal miner, like me and so many of us around, you consider folks like this heroes because if maybe they wouldn’t have died so tragically on the job there would never have been a day that helped safety become a priority in the work place and it would be the obligation for coal operators to provide us a safe place to work.”*

Four of those heroes have the same last name: Murphy.

• James Bernard Murphy, Melissa’s great-grandfather
• James Lewis Murphy, Melissa’s great-uncle and the son of James Bernard Murphy
• George Bernard Murphy, Melissa’s 2^nd great-uncle and brother of James Bernard Murphy
• Kenny A. Murphy – died five years after the explosion in 1933. I presume there is a relationship, but it has yet to be established.

 Not only did James Bernard, James Lewis, and George Bernard all die on the same day – April 30, 1927, but they were all buried on the same day – May 7, 1927, in Saint Michael's Cemetery, Frostburg, Maryland. 

If you are interested, here is the link to the government report on this mine disaster. (click here)

Mine entrance before the explosion

Mine before the explosion

All that is left of No. 3 Mine

---

Note:  All photos are from the Everettville (WV) Historical Association

*Goodrich, Sarah. "Miners remembered as 'heroes' at Federal No. 3 service." Timeswv.com, 30 April 2017, www.timeswv.com/news/miners-remembered-as-heroes-at-federal-no-service/article_ 2daa5098-2d79-11e7-99cb-07ed20410f7d.html. Accessed 7 July 2017.